Karachi’s new automated traffic ticketing system, Traffic Regulation and Citation System (TRACS), has sparked controversy. Within hours of its launch, thousands of e-challans were reportedly issued — generating millions of rupees in fines.
The system uses AI-powered CCTV to detect violations like not wearing seatbelts, speeding, red-light jumping, and riding without helmets. Supporters argue TRACS will instill discipline and improve road safety, but critics say it’s more about revenue collection than reform.
Public backlash has been significant: legal petitions have been filed, with Jamaat-e-Islami (JI) leading the criticism. JI claims the fines are excessive and unfair, especially given Karachi’s deteriorating road infrastructure and lack of proper signage. One petition notes that many vehicle owners received tickets even though they were not behind the wheel at the time of the alleged violation.
A particularly controversial case involved a motorist who received five separate challans in one day, totaling Rs 50,000. Critics say the system lacks empathy: enforcement is strict, but the government has not done enough to earn public trust.
JI also accuses the government of exploiting the system to fill its coffers, accusing authorities of turning e-challans into a “organized loot.” The debate also reflects a broader tension: citizens demand not just law enforcement, but fairness and better public services.
Read latest news and updates at supernews.pk